Pros of react-native-modal

• More versatile, can create various types of modals beyond action sheets
• Highly customizable with extensive styling options
• Supports custom animations and transitions

Cons of react-native-modal

• Requires more setup and configuration for basic use cases
• May have a steeper learning curve for beginners
• Potentially larger bundle size due to additional features

Code Comparison

react-native-modal:

<Modal isVisible={isModalVisible} onBackdropPress={toggleModal}>
  <View style={styles.modalContent}>
    <Text>Hello!</Text>
    <Button title="Hide modal" onPress={toggleModal} />
  </View>
</Modal>

react-native-action-sheet:

showActionSheetWithOptions(
  {
    options: ['Cancel', 'Option 1', 'Option 2'],
    cancelButtonIndex: 0,
  },
  (buttonIndex) => {
    // Handle button press
  }
);

The react-native-modal example shows a more flexible approach for creating custom modal content, while react-native-action-sheet provides a simpler API for creating action sheets specifically. react-native-modal requires more setup but offers greater customization, whereas react-native-action-sheet is more straightforward for its specific use case.

Pros of react-native-paper

• Comprehensive UI component library with a wide range of pre-built components
• Material Design implementation for consistent and modern look
• Active development and regular updates

Cons of react-native-paper

• Larger package size due to extensive component library
• May require additional configuration for custom theming
• Learning curve for utilizing all available components

Code Comparison

react-native-paper:

import { Button } from 'react-native-paper';

const MyComponent = () => (
  <Button mode="contained" onPress={() => console.log('Pressed')}>
    Press me
  </Button>
);

react-native-action-sheet:

import { connectActionSheet } from '@expo/react-native-action-sheet';

const MyComponent = ({ showActionSheetWithOptions }) => {
  const openActionSheet = () => {
    showActionSheetWithOptions(
      { options: ['Option 1', 'Option 2', 'Cancel'], cancelButtonIndex: 2 },
      (selectedIndex) => { /* Handle selection */ }
    );
  };
  return <Button onPress={openActionSheet}>Open Action Sheet</Button>;
};

export default connectActionSheet(MyComponent);

react-native-paper offers a more comprehensive set of UI components, while react-native-action-sheet focuses specifically on providing an action sheet functionality. The code comparison shows the simplicity of using a button in react-native-paper versus the more involved setup required for an action sheet in react-native-action-sheet.

Pros of react-native-picker

• Native implementation for both iOS and Android platforms
• Supports a wide range of customization options
• Seamless integration with React Native core components

Cons of react-native-picker

• Limited to picker-style selection, less versatile than action sheets
• Requires more setup and configuration compared to action sheets
• May have inconsistent behavior across different device sizes

Code Comparison

react-native-picker:

import {Picker} from '@react-native-picker/picker';

<Picker
  selectedValue={selectedValue}
  onValueChange={(itemValue, itemIndex) => setSelectedValue(itemValue)}
>
  <Picker.Item label="Option 1" value="option1" />
  <Picker.Item label="Option 2" value="option2" />
</Picker>

react-native-action-sheet:

import {useActionSheet} from '@expo/react-native-action-sheet';

const {showActionSheetWithOptions} = useActionSheet();

showActionSheetWithOptions(
  {
    options: ['Option 1', 'Option 2', 'Cancel'],
    cancelButtonIndex: 2,
  },
  (selectedIndex) => {
    // Handle selection
  }
);

Summary

react-native-picker offers a native picker component with extensive customization options, while react-native-action-sheet provides a more versatile action sheet interface. The choice between the two depends on the specific UI requirements and the desired user interaction style for your React Native application.

Pros of datetimepicker

• Specialized for date and time selection, offering a more focused and user-friendly interface for these specific inputs
• Provides native date and time picker components for both iOS and Android platforms
• Offers more customization options for date and time formats, including minimum and maximum selectable dates

Cons of datetimepicker

• Limited to date and time selection, lacking the versatility of react-native-action-sheet for general-purpose action sheets
• May require additional setup and configuration compared to the simpler implementation of react-native-action-sheet
• Potentially larger package size due to its specialized nature and platform-specific implementations

Code Comparison

datetimepicker:

import DateTimePicker from '@react-native-community/datetimepicker';

<DateTimePicker
  value={date}
  mode="date"
  display="default"
  onChange={onChange}
/>

react-native-action-sheet:

import { connectActionSheet } from '@expo/react-native-action-sheet';

const showActionSheet = () => {
  this.props.showActionSheetWithOptions(
    {
      options: ['Option 1', 'Option 2', 'Cancel'],
      cancelButtonIndex: 2,
    },
    (buttonIndex) => {
      // Handle button press
    }
  );
};

The code comparison demonstrates the different use cases and implementations of these libraries. datetimepicker focuses on date and time selection with a specialized component, while react-native-action-sheet provides a more general-purpose action sheet functionality.

Pros of Menu

• More customizable UI with support for nested submenus
• Offers a wider variety of menu types (e.g., context menu, dropdown)
• Better suited for complex menu structures and hierarchical navigation

Cons of Menu

• Less native-feeling on iOS compared to Action Sheet
• May require more setup and configuration for basic use cases
• Less frequently updated and maintained compared to Action Sheet

Code Comparison

Menu:

<Menu>
  <MenuTrigger text='Select action' />
  <MenuOptions>
    <MenuOption onSelect={() => alert('Option 1')} text='Option 1' />
    <MenuOption onSelect={() => alert('Option 2')} text='Option 2' />
  </MenuOptions>
</Menu>

Action Sheet:

showActionSheetWithOptions(
  {
    options: ['Option 1', 'Option 2', 'Cancel'],
    cancelButtonIndex: 2,
  },
  (buttonIndex) => {
    if (buttonIndex === 0) alert('Option 1');
    else if (buttonIndex === 1) alert('Option 2');
  }
);

Summary

Menu offers more flexibility and customization options, making it suitable for complex menu structures. However, Action Sheet provides a more native iOS experience and is easier to implement for simple use cases. The choice between the two depends on the specific requirements of your project and the desired user experience.