Pros of Vimwiki

• Mature and stable project with a large user base
• Simpler setup and learning curve for beginners
• Built-in diary functionality

Cons of Vimwiki

• Limited extensibility compared to Neorg
• Less powerful markup language
• Lack of advanced features like task management and project planning

Code Comparison

Vimwiki syntax:

= Header 1 =
== Header 2 ==
* List item
[[Link]]

Neorg syntax:

* Header 1
** Header 2
- List item
{:link:}[Link]

Key Differences

• Neorg is specifically designed for Neovim, while Vimwiki works with both Vim and Neovim
• Neorg uses a more powerful and flexible markup language (Norg)
• Neorg offers better integration with other Neovim plugins and ecosystems
• Vimwiki has a simpler syntax, making it easier for beginners to get started
• Neorg provides more advanced features like task management and project planning

Conclusion

Vimwiki is a solid choice for users looking for a simple, stable note-taking solution within Vim or Neovim. Neorg, on the other hand, offers more advanced features and extensibility, making it ideal for power users who want to create a comprehensive personal knowledge management system within Neovim.

Pros of vim-orgmode

• More mature and stable, with a longer development history
• Closer to the original Emacs Org-mode functionality
• Works with both Vim and Neovim

Cons of vim-orgmode

• Less active development and slower updates
• Limited extensibility compared to Neorg's modular architecture
• Lacks some advanced features present in Neorg

Code Comparison

vim-orgmode:

" Basic todo item
* TODO Write comparison
** DONE Research repositories
** TODO Draft content

Neorg:

@document.meta
title: Comparison
description: Repository comparison
authors: [Your Name]
@end

* TODO Write comparison
** DONE Research repositories
** TODO Draft content

Key Differences

• Neorg is built specifically for Neovim, leveraging its advanced features
• Neorg uses a custom markup language, while vim-orgmode aims to be more compatible with Emacs Org-mode
• Neorg offers a more modular and extensible architecture
• vim-orgmode provides a more familiar experience for users transitioning from Emacs Org-mode

Conclusion

Both projects aim to bring Org-mode-like functionality to Vim/Neovim users. vim-orgmode is more established and closer to the original Org-mode, while Neorg offers a modern, Neovim-specific approach with greater extensibility and custom features.

Pros of vim-markdown

• Lightweight and focused solely on Markdown support
• Extensive syntax highlighting and folding features
• Compatible with both Vim and Neovim

Cons of vim-markdown

• Limited to Markdown functionality only
• Lacks advanced organizational features and task management
• No built-in support for linking between notes or creating knowledge bases

Code comparison

vim-markdown:

" Enable TOC window auto-fit
let g:vim_markdown_toc_autofit = 1

" Disable folding
let g:vim_markdown_folding_disabled = 1

Neorg:

require('neorg').setup {
  load = {
    ["core.defaults"] = {},
    ["core.concealer"] = {},
    ["core.dirman"] = {
      config = {
        workspaces = {
          notes = "~/notes",
        },
      },
    },
  },
}

Summary

vim-markdown is a lightweight plugin focused on Markdown support, offering excellent syntax highlighting and folding features. It's compatible with both Vim and Neovim, making it a versatile choice for Markdown editing.

Neorg, on the other hand, is a more comprehensive note-taking and organization system built specifically for Neovim. It offers advanced features like workspaces, task management, and linking between notes, making it suitable for creating complex knowledge bases.

While vim-markdown excels in its simplicity and Markdown-specific functionality, Neorg provides a more robust ecosystem for note-taking and personal knowledge management beyond just Markdown support.

Pros of markdown-preview.nvim

• Lightweight and focused solely on Markdown preview
• Real-time preview in browser with automatic refresh
• Easy to set up and use with minimal configuration

Cons of markdown-preview.nvim

• Limited to Markdown format only
• Lacks advanced organization and note-taking features
• No built-in support for task management or linking between notes

Code Comparison

markdown-preview.nvim:

vim.g.mkdp_auto_start = 1
vim.g.mkdp_browser = 'firefox'
vim.g.mkdp_preview_options = {
    disable_sync_scroll = 0,
}

neorg:

require('neorg').setup {
    load = {
        ["core.defaults"] = {},
        ["core.concealer"] = {},
        ["core.dirman"] = {
            config = { workspaces = { notes = "~/notes" } }
        }
    }
}

Summary

markdown-preview.nvim is a lightweight plugin focused on providing real-time Markdown preview in the browser. It's easy to set up and use but limited to Markdown format. neorg, on the other hand, is a comprehensive note-taking and organization system with support for multiple formats, advanced linking, and task management. neorg offers more features but requires more setup and learning. Choose based on your specific needs: simple Markdown preview or a full-fledged note-taking system.

Pros of telekasten.nvim

• Lightweight and focused specifically on Zettelkasten note-taking
• Easier to set up and configure for users who only need Zettelkasten functionality
• Integrates well with existing Markdown workflows

Cons of telekasten.nvim

• Less feature-rich compared to Neorg's comprehensive organizational capabilities
• Limited to Markdown format, while Neorg offers a custom markup language
• Smaller community and ecosystem compared to Neorg

Code Comparison

telekasten.nvim:

require('telekasten').setup({
    home = vim.fn.expand("~/zettelkasten"),
    template_new_note = vim.fn.expand("~/zettelkasten/templates/new_note.md"),
})

Neorg:

require('neorg').setup {
    load = {
        ["core.defaults"] = {},
        ["core.concealer"] = {},
        ["core.dirman"] = {
            config = {
                workspaces = {
                    notes = "~/notes",
                }
            }
        }
    }
}

Both plugins offer configuration options, but Neorg's setup is more extensive due to its broader feature set. telekasten.nvim focuses on Zettelkasten-specific settings, while Neorg provides a modular structure for various organizational tools.