php-ext-xlsxwriter

Pros of PHP_XLSXWriter

• Pure PHP implementation, no external dependencies required
• Easy to install and use in any PHP environment
• More flexible for customization and integration into existing PHP projects

Cons of PHP_XLSXWriter

• Generally slower performance compared to the C extension
• May consume more memory for large datasets
• Limited support for advanced Excel features

Code Comparison

PHP_XLSXWriter:

$writer = new XLSXWriter();
$writer->writeSheetHeader('Sheet1', array('Col1' => 'string', 'Col2' => 'integer'));
$writer->writeSheetRow('Sheet1', array('Hello', 123));
$writer->writeToFile('example.xlsx');

php-ext-xlsxwriter:

$config = ['path' => './example.xlsx'];
$excel = new \Vtiful\Kernel\Excel($config);
$filePath = $excel->fileName('tutorial01.xlsx', 'sheet1')
    ->header(['name', 'age'])
    ->data([['viest', 21]])
    ->output();

Both libraries offer straightforward APIs for creating Excel files, but PHP_XLSXWriter uses a more traditional object-oriented approach, while php-ext-xlsxwriter employs a fluent interface. The C extension (php-ext-xlsxwriter) is likely to provide better performance for large datasets or frequent file generation, while PHP_XLSXWriter offers greater flexibility and easier integration into pure PHP environments.

Pros of PhpSpreadsheet

• More feature-rich, supporting a wide range of spreadsheet operations
• Pure PHP implementation, easier to install and use without system dependencies
• Supports reading and writing multiple file formats (XLSX, XLS, CSV, ODS)

Cons of PhpSpreadsheet

• Slower performance, especially for large datasets
• Higher memory usage due to its pure PHP implementation
• Steeper learning curve due to more complex API

Code Comparison

PhpSpreadsheet:

$spreadsheet = new Spreadsheet();
$sheet = $spreadsheet->getActiveSheet();
$sheet->setCellValue('A1', 'Hello World');
$writer = new Xlsx($spreadsheet);
$writer->save('hello_world.xlsx');

php-ext-xlsxwriter:

$config = ['path' => './'];
$excel = new \Vtiful\Kernel\Excel($config);
$filePath = $excel->fileName('tutorial.xlsx')
    ->header(['name', 'age'])
    ->data([['viest', 21]])
    ->output();

PhpSpreadsheet offers a more intuitive API for cell manipulation, while php-ext-xlsxwriter focuses on simplicity and performance for basic spreadsheet creation. The php-ext-xlsxwriter example demonstrates its streamlined approach to creating a file with headers and data in fewer lines of code.

Pros of Spout

• Pure PHP implementation, no need for extensions or additional libraries
• Supports reading and writing multiple formats (XLSX, CSV, ODS)
• Memory-efficient streaming for large files

Cons of Spout

• Generally slower performance compared to native extensions
• Limited formatting options for created spreadsheets
• Lacks some advanced features available in php-ext-xlsxwriter

Code Comparison

php-ext-xlsxwriter:

$config = ['path' => '/path/to/file.xlsx'];
$excel  = new \Vtiful\Kernel\Excel($config);

$filePath = $excel->fileName('tutorial01.xlsx')
    ->header(['Item', 'Cost'])
    ->data([['Rent', 1000], ['Gas', 100]])
    ->output();

Spout:

$writer = WriterFactory::create(Type::XLSX);
$writer->openToFile($filePath);

$writer->addRow(['Item', 'Cost']);
$writer->addRows([['Rent', 1000], ['Gas', 100]]);

$writer->close();

Both libraries offer straightforward APIs for creating Excel files. php-ext-xlsxwriter uses a fluent interface, while Spout employs a more traditional method-calling approach. The php-ext-xlsxwriter example showcases its ability to define headers and data in a single chain, whereas Spout separates these operations into distinct method calls.

Pros of XlsxWriter

• Written in Python, offering better integration with Python-based projects
• More comprehensive documentation and examples
• Supports a wider range of Excel features and formatting options

Cons of XlsxWriter

• Slower performance compared to php-ext-xlsxwriter
• Requires Python installation and setup, which may not be ideal for PHP-centric environments

Code Comparison

XlsxWriter:

import xlsxwriter

workbook = xlsxwriter.Workbook('example.xlsx')
worksheet = workbook.add_worksheet()
worksheet.write('A1', 'Hello World')
workbook.close()

php-ext-xlsxwriter:

$config = ['path' => './example.xlsx'];
$excel  = new \Vtiful\Kernel\Excel($config);

$excel->fileName('tutorial01.xlsx', 'sheet1')
    ->header(['Item', 'Cost'])
    ->output();

Both libraries offer straightforward ways to create Excel files, but XlsxWriter provides more flexibility in terms of formatting and cell manipulation. php-ext-xlsxwriter, being a PHP extension, is likely to offer better performance for PHP applications.

The choice between these libraries depends on the specific project requirements, programming language preference, and performance needs. XlsxWriter is more suitable for Python-based projects or when advanced Excel features are required, while php-ext-xlsxwriter is better for PHP environments where speed is a priority.

Pros of simplexlsx

• Pure PHP implementation, no extensions required
• Easy to use and integrate into existing PHP projects
• Supports reading and writing Excel files

Cons of simplexlsx

• Slower performance compared to native extensions
• Limited formatting options for writing Excel files
• May consume more memory for large files

Code Comparison

simplexlsx:

$xlsx = SimpleXLSX::parse('file.xlsx');
foreach ($xlsx->rows() as $row) {
    print_r($row);
}

php-ext-xlsxwriter:

$config = ['path' => '/path/to/file.xlsx'];
$excel = new \Vtiful\Kernel\Excel($config);
$filePath = $excel->fileName('file.xlsx')
    ->header(['name', 'age'])
    ->data([['John', 28], ['Jane', 25]])
    ->output();

simplexlsx offers a straightforward approach to reading Excel files, while php-ext-xlsxwriter provides a more efficient method for writing Excel files with better performance. The choice between the two depends on specific project requirements, such as the need for native extension support, performance considerations, and the complexity of Excel operations required.

Pros of PHPExcel

• More feature-rich, supporting a wide range of Excel functionalities
• Better documentation and community support
• Cross-platform compatibility (works on various PHP environments)

Cons of PHPExcel

• Slower performance, especially for large datasets
• Higher memory consumption
• Requires more setup and configuration

Code Comparison

PHPExcel:

$objPHPExcel = new PHPExcel();
$objPHPExcel->getActiveSheet()->setCellValue('A1', 'Hello');
$objPHPExcel->getActiveSheet()->setCellValue('B2', 'World');
$objWriter = PHPExcel_IOFactory::createWriter($objPHPExcel, 'Excel2007');
$objWriter->save('myfile.xlsx');

php-ext-xlsxwriter:

$config = ['path' => './'];
$excel = new \Vtiful\Kernel\Excel($config);
$filePath = $excel->fileName('tutorial01.xlsx')
    ->header(['Item', 'Cost'])
    ->output();

php-ext-xlsxwriter is a PHP extension that offers faster performance and lower memory usage compared to PHPExcel. It's particularly efficient for generating large Excel files. However, it has fewer features and may require additional setup as it's an extension rather than a pure PHP library. The code for php-ext-xlsxwriter is generally more concise, as shown in the comparison above.