Vscode vs Core
Detailed comparison of features, pros, cons, and usage
VS Code (microsoft/vscode) is a widely-adopted, feature-rich open-source code editor with extensive plugin support, while OpenSumi (opensumi/core) is a more lightweight, customizable IDE framework aimed at building web-based development tools, offering greater flexibility but with a smaller ecosystem compared to VS Code.
A framework helps you quickly build AI Native IDE products. MCP Client, supports Model Context Protocol (MCP) tools via MCP server.
Vscode Pros and Cons
Pros
- Extensive ecosystem: VS Code has a vast library of extensions, themes, and plugins, making it highly customizable for various programming languages and workflows.
- Regular updates: Microsoft frequently releases updates with new features, bug fixes, and performance improvements, ensuring the editor stays current and competitive.
- Cross-platform compatibility: VS Code runs on Windows, macOS, and Linux, providing a consistent development experience across different operating systems.
- Integrated terminal and Git support: Built-in terminal and Git integration streamline development workflows and version control tasks.
Cons
- Resource consumption: VS Code can be resource-intensive, especially when multiple extensions are installed, potentially slowing down older or less powerful machines.
- Learning curve for advanced features: While the basic functionality is intuitive, mastering all of VS Code's features and shortcuts may require time and effort.
- Electron-based limitations: Being built on Electron, VS Code may not be as performant as some native code editors, particularly for very large files or projects.
- Potential privacy concerns: Some users may have reservations about Microsoft's data collection practices, although telemetry can be disabled in the settings.
Core Pros and Cons
Pros
-
Extensible Architecture: OpenSumi provides a highly extensible and modular architecture, allowing developers to easily customize and extend the IDE framework to suit their specific needs.
-
Rich Feature Set: The framework offers a comprehensive set of features out of the box, including file management, code editing, debugging, and version control integration.
-
Active Development: The project is actively maintained and regularly updated, ensuring that users have access to the latest improvements and bug fixes.
-
Cross-platform Support: OpenSumi is designed to work across multiple platforms, making it versatile for various development environments.
Cons
-
Learning Curve: Due to its extensive feature set and modular architecture, there may be a steeper learning curve for developers new to the framework.
-
Documentation Challenges: While documentation exists, some users might find it lacking in certain areas or not as comprehensive as they would like, especially for more advanced use cases.
-
Limited Community: Compared to some other popular IDE frameworks, OpenSumi has a smaller community, which may result in fewer third-party extensions and resources.
-
Performance Overhead: As with many extensible frameworks, there might be some performance overhead compared to more lightweight or specialized IDEs, especially for large projects.
Vscode Code Examples
Extension API Usage
This snippet demonstrates how to create a simple VS Code extension that adds a new command:
import * as vscode from 'vscode';
export function activate(context: vscode.ExtensionContext) {
let disposable = vscode.commands.registerCommand('extension.helloWorld', () => {
vscode.window.showInformationMessage('Hello World from VS Code!');
});
context.subscriptions.push(disposable);
}
Language Server Protocol Implementation
This snippet shows how VS Code implements the Language Server Protocol for providing language features:
import * as lsp from 'vscode-languageserver-protocol';
connection.onCompletion(
(textDocumentPosition: lsp.TextDocumentPositionParams): lsp.CompletionItem[] => {
return [
{ label: 'TypeScript', kind: lsp.CompletionItemKind.Text },
{ label: 'JavaScript', kind: lsp.CompletionItemKind.Text }
];
}
);
Custom Editor API
This snippet demonstrates how to create a custom editor in VS Code:
class CustomEditor implements vscode.CustomTextEditorProvider {
resolveCustomTextEditor(
document: vscode.TextDocument,
webviewPanel: vscode.WebviewPanel,
token: vscode.CancellationToken
): void | Thenable<void> {
webviewPanel.webview.html = this.getHtmlForWebview(webviewPanel.webview);
// Set up communication between the webview and extension
}
}
Core Code Examples
Extension API Usage
This snippet demonstrates how to use the Extension API to register a command and add it to the menu:
import { Injectable, Autowired } from '@opensumi/di';
import { IMenuRegistry, ICommandService, CommandRegistry } from '@opensumi/ide-core-browser';
@Injectable()
export class MyExtension {
@Autowired(IMenuRegistry)
private menuRegistry: IMenuRegistry;
@Autowired(ICommandService)
private commandService: ICommandService;
activate() {
CommandRegistry.registerCommand({ id: 'myCommand', execute: () => console.log('Command executed') });
this.menuRegistry.registerMenuItem(MenuId.EditorContext, { command: 'myCommand', group: '1_modification' });
}
}
File System Provider Implementation
This snippet shows how to implement a custom file system provider:
import { Injectable } from '@opensumi/di';
import { URI, IFileSystemProvider, FileSystemProviderCapabilities } from '@opensumi/ide-core-browser';
@Injectable()
export class CustomFileSystemProvider implements IFileSystemProvider {
capabilities = FileSystemProviderCapabilities.FileRead | FileSystemProviderCapabilities.FileWrite;
async readFile(resource: URI): Promise<Uint8Array> {
// Custom implementation to read file
}
async writeFile(resource: URI, content: Uint8Array, opts: FileWriteOptions): Promise<void> {
// Custom implementation to write file
}
}
Vscode Quick Start
Installation
- Visit the Visual Studio Code website.
- Download the appropriate version for your operating system (Windows, macOS, or Linux).
- Run the installer and follow the on-screen instructions.
Basic Usage
Opening a Project
- Launch Visual Studio Code.
- Click on "File" > "Open Folder" in the top menu.
- Select the folder containing your project files.
Creating a New File
- In the Explorer sidebar, right-click on the folder where you want to create the file.
- Select "New File" from the context menu.
- Enter the file name with the appropriate extension (e.g.,
index.html
orscript.js
).
Editing and Saving
- Open a file by clicking on it in the Explorer sidebar.
- Make your changes in the editor.
- Save the file by pressing
Ctrl+S
(Windows/Linux) orCmd+S
(macOS).
Example: Creating an HTML File
- Create a new file named
index.html
. - Copy and paste the following HTML code:
<!DOCTYPE html>
<html lang="en">
<head>
<meta charset="UTF-8">
<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0">
<title>My First VS Code Project</title>
</head>
<body>
<h1>Hello, World!</h1>
<p>This is my first project using Visual Studio Code.</p>
</body>
</html>
- Save the file.
- Right-click on the file in the Explorer sidebar and select "Open with Live Server" (you may need to install the Live Server extension first).
This will open your HTML file in a web browser, allowing you to see the results of your code.
Core Quick Start
Installation
To get started with OpenSumi Core, follow these steps:
-
Ensure you have Node.js (version 14 or later) installed on your system.
-
Clone the repository:
git clone https://github.com/opensumi/core.git
cd core
- Install dependencies:
yarn install
Basic Usage
Here's a simple example of how to use OpenSumi Core in your project:
-
Create a new file called
example.ts
in your project directory. -
Add the following code to
example.ts
:
import { Injector } from '@opensumi/di';
import { BrowserModule } from '@opensumi/ide-core-browser';
const injector = new Injector([BrowserModule]);
const app = injector.get(BrowserModule);
app.start().then(() => {
console.log('OpenSumi Core application started');
});
- Run the example:
ts-node example.ts
This basic example initializes the OpenSumi Core application with the BrowserModule. You can expand on this by adding more modules and customizing the application according to your needs.
For more detailed information and advanced usage, please refer to the official documentation.
Top Related Projects
Eclipse Theia is a cloud & desktop IDE framework implemented in TypeScript.
Pros of Theia
- More flexible and customizable architecture than VS Code
- Better support for creating domain-specific IDEs
- Easier to embed in web applications compared to VS Code and OpenSumi
Cons of Theia
- Smaller ecosystem and extension marketplace than VS Code
- Less mature and stable compared to VS Code
- Steeper learning curve for developers compared to OpenSumi
Code Comparison
VS Code (TypeScript):
export class EditorContribution implements IEditorContribution {
public static readonly ID = 'editor.contrib.folding';
constructor(editor: ICodeEditor) {
// Implementation
}
}
Theia (TypeScript):
@injectable()
export class EditorContribution implements FrontendApplicationContribution {
@inject(EditorManager)
protected readonly editorManager: EditorManager;
configure(app: FrontendApplication): void {
// Implementation
}
}
OpenSumi (TypeScript):
@Injectable()
export class EditorContribution implements IEditorContribution {
@Autowired(IEditorService)
private editorService: IEditorService;
activate(editor: ICodeEditor): void {
// Implementation
}
}
The code snippets show differences in dependency injection and class structure between the three projects, highlighting Theia's use of the @injectable()
decorator and OpenSumi's @Injectable()
and @Autowired()
decorators.
:atom: The hackable text editor
Pros of Atom
- Highly customizable with a large ecosystem of packages and themes
- Built on web technologies, making it easier for web developers to extend
- Simple and intuitive interface for beginners
Cons of Atom
- Performance issues with large files and projects
- Development has been discontinued, limiting future updates and support
- Less integrated features compared to VS Code and OpenSumi
Code Comparison
VS Code (TypeScript):
export class TextEditor implements vscode.TextEditor {
private _document: vscode.TextDocument;
constructor(document: vscode.TextDocument) {
this._document = document;
}
}
OpenSumi (TypeScript):
@Injectable()
export class EditorService {
private editors: Map<string, IEditor> = new Map();
public openEditor(uri: URI): Promise<IEditor> {
// Implementation
}
}
Atom (CoffeeScript):
class TextEditor
constructor: (@buffer, @displayBuffer, @id) ->
@emitter = new Emitter
@subscriptions = new CompositeDisposable
@alive = true
Note: VS Code and OpenSumi use TypeScript, while Atom uses CoffeeScript. VS Code and OpenSumi have more modern codebases with better type support and maintainability. Atom's codebase, while innovative for its time, is now considered outdated.
IntelliJ IDEA Community Edition & IntelliJ Platform
Pros of intellij-community
- Extensive language support and advanced code analysis
- Powerful refactoring tools and intelligent code completion
- Highly customizable with a wide range of plugins
Cons of intellij-community
- Heavier resource usage compared to vscode and core
- Steeper learning curve for new users
- Slower startup time and potentially longer indexing process
Code Comparison
intellij-community (Java):
public class HelloWorld {
public static void main(String[] args) {
System.out.println("Hello, World!");
}
}
vscode (TypeScript):
export function activate(context: vscode.ExtensionContext) {
console.log('Congratulations, your extension "vscode" is now active!');
}
core (TypeScript):
import { ClientApp, IClientAppOpts } from '@opensumi/ide-core-browser';
const app = new ClientApp(opts);
app.start();
The code snippets showcase the different focus areas of each project. intellij-community emphasizes Java development, vscode demonstrates extension activation, and core illustrates the client-side application setup for the OpenSumi framework. While all three projects aim to provide development environments, they cater to different use cases and preferences in terms of language support, extensibility, and resource requirements.
Run upstream VS Code on a remote machine with access through a modern web browser from any device, anywhere.
Pros of openvscode-server
- Optimized for cloud-based development environments
- Lightweight and easily deployable in containerized setups
- Provides a browser-based VS Code experience without local installation
Cons of openvscode-server
- Limited feature set compared to full VS Code
- May lack some extensions and customization options
- Potentially slower performance for complex development tasks
Code Comparison
vscode:
export class ExtensionHostProcessManager extends Disposable {
private readonly _onDidExit = this._register(new Emitter<[number, string | null]>());
readonly onDidExit = this._onDidExit.event;
// ...
}
openvscode-server:
export class ExtensionHostProcessManager extends Disposable {
private readonly _onDidExit = this._register(new Emitter<[number, string | null]>());
readonly onDidExit = this._onDidExit.event;
// ...
}
core:
export class ExtensionHostProcessManager extends Disposable {
private readonly _onDidExit = new Emitter<[number, string | null]>();
readonly onDidExit = this._onDidExit.event;
// ...
}
The code structure is similar across all three projects, with minor differences in implementation details. openvscode-server and vscode share nearly identical code, while core has slight variations in class structure and event handling.
VS Code in the browser
Pros of code-server
- Enables running VS Code in a browser, allowing access from any device
- Supports remote development and collaboration out of the box
- Can be self-hosted for enhanced security and control
Cons of code-server
- May have performance limitations compared to native VS Code
- Requires additional setup and maintenance for self-hosting
- Some VS Code extensions may not be fully compatible
Code Comparison
VS Code (vscode):
import * as vscode from 'vscode';
export function activate(context: vscode.ExtensionContext) {
console.log('VS Code extension activated');
}
code-server:
import * as codeServer from '@coder/code-server';
codeServer.launch({
port: 8080,
auth: 'password'
});
OpenSumi (core):
import { ClientApp } from '@opensumi/ide-core-browser';
const app = new ClientApp({
modules: [],
layoutConfig: {}
});
The code snippets demonstrate the basic setup for each project. VS Code focuses on extension development, code-server emphasizes launching a server instance, and OpenSumi showcases client-side application initialization. While all three projects aim to provide IDE-like functionality, their implementation approaches and primary use cases differ.