QBittorrent vs Webtorrent-desktop
Detailed comparison of features, pros, cons, and usage
The qBittorrent repository offers a full-featured, cross-platform BitTorrent client with a robust feature set, while the webtorrent-desktop repository provides a more lightweight, browser-based solution for streaming torrents, with the trade-off of potentially less comprehensive functionality compared to qBittorrent.
QBittorrent Pros and Cons
Pros
-
Open-source and free: qBittorrent is a free, open-source BitTorrent client, allowing users to benefit from community contributions and transparency.
-
Cross-platform compatibility: Available for Windows, macOS, Linux, and FreeBSD, making it accessible to a wide range of users.
-
Feature-rich: Offers a comprehensive set of features including sequential downloading, torrent creation, and RSS feed support.
-
User-friendly interface: Provides an intuitive and clean interface, making it easy for both beginners and advanced users to navigate and use.
Cons
-
Limited mobile support: Unlike some competitors, qBittorrent lacks official mobile apps for iOS and Android platforms.
-
Occasional stability issues: Some users report crashes or freezes, particularly with large numbers of torrents or on certain system configurations.
-
Less frequent updates: Development cycles can be slower compared to some other BitTorrent clients, potentially leading to delayed feature implementations or bug fixes.
-
Limited cloud integration: Lacks built-in support for cloud storage services, which some users may find inconvenient for remote access or backup purposes.
Webtorrent-desktop Pros and Cons
Pros
- Cross-platform compatibility: Runs on Windows, macOS, and Linux, providing a consistent experience across different operating systems.
- Open-source: The project is open-source, allowing for community contributions and transparency in development.
- User-friendly interface: Offers a simple and intuitive interface for streaming and downloading torrents.
- Streaming capability: Allows users to stream media files while they are still downloading, providing instant playback.
Cons
- Limited active development: The project has seen reduced activity in recent years, which may impact future updates and bug fixes.
- Resource intensive: Can be demanding on system resources, especially when handling multiple torrents or large files.
- Potential legal concerns: As with any torrent client, users need to be cautious about copyright infringement and adhere to local laws.
- Limited advanced features: Compared to some other torrent clients, it may lack certain advanced features for power users.
QBittorrent Code Examples
Torrent Addition
This snippet demonstrates how to add a torrent to qBittorrent using the WebUI API:
import requests
url = "http://localhost:8080/api/v2/torrents/add"
files = {'torrents': open('example.torrent', 'rb')}
data = {
'savepath': '/downloads',
'category': 'movies',
'paused': 'false'
}
response = requests.post(url, files=files, data=data)
Torrent Management
Here's an example of how to pause, resume, and delete torrents using the API:
import qbittorrentapi
qbt_client = qbittorrentapi.Client(host='localhost:8080')
qbt_client.auth_log_in()
torrent_hash = 'example_hash'
qbt_client.torrents_pause(torrent_hashes=torrent_hash)
qbt_client.torrents_resume(torrent_hashes=torrent_hash)
qbt_client.torrents_delete(delete_files=True, torrent_hashes=torrent_hash)
RSS Feed Management
This snippet shows how to add and manage RSS feeds in qBittorrent:
from qbittorrent import Client
qb = Client('http://127.0.0.1:8080/')
qb.login('admin', 'adminadmin')
qb.add_feed('http://example.com/rss_feed')
qb.set_feed_rule('Example Rule', 'example', 'movies', '/downloads/movies')
feeds = qb.feeds()
print(feeds)
Webtorrent-desktop Code Examples
Torrent Streaming
This snippet demonstrates how to create a WebTorrent client and stream a torrent:
const WebTorrent = require('webtorrent')
const client = new WebTorrent()
client.add('magnet:?xt=urn:btih:...', function (torrent) {
const file = torrent.files.find(function (file) {
return file.name.endsWith('.mp4')
})
file.renderTo('video#player')
})
Adding Torrents to the Client
Here's how to add torrents to the WebTorrent Desktop client:
const electron = require('electron')
const ipc = electron.ipcRenderer
function addTorrent (torrentId) {
ipc.send('wt-start-torrenting', torrentId)
}
addTorrent('magnet:?xt=urn:btih:...')
addTorrent('https://example.com/movie.torrent')
QBittorrent Quick Start
Installation
Windows
- Download the installer from the official qBittorrent website.
- Run the installer and follow the on-screen instructions.
macOS
- Install Homebrew if you haven't already:
/bin/bash -c "$(curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Homebrew/install/HEAD/install.sh)"
- Install qBittorrent using Homebrew:
brew install qbittorrent
Linux (Ubuntu/Debian)
- Add the qBittorrent PPA:
sudo add-apt-repository ppa:qbittorrent-team/qbittorrent-stable
- Update package list and install qBittorrent:
sudo apt update sudo apt install qbittorrent
Basic Usage
-
Launch qBittorrent from your applications menu or command line.
-
Add a torrent:
- Click on the "+" button in the toolbar
- Select "Add Torrent Link" or "Add Torrent File"
- Enter the magnet link or select the .torrent file
-
Configure download settings:
- Right-click on the added torrent
- Select "Set Location" to choose where to save the downloaded files
-
Start the download:
- The torrent will start automatically if "Start torrent" was checked when adding
- Otherwise, right-click on the torrent and select "Resume"
-
Monitor progress:
- The main window displays download progress, speed, and other details
- Use the tabs at the bottom to view more information about the torrent
Advanced Configuration
To access advanced settings:
- Go to Tools > Options (or Preferences on macOS)
- Explore the various tabs to customize qBittorrent's behavior, including:
- Downloads: Set default save path, seeding limits, etc.
- Connection: Configure network settings and port forwarding
- BitTorrent: Adjust protocol-specific options
- RSS: Set up automatic downloads based on RSS feeds
Webtorrent-desktop Quick Start
Installation
-
Ensure you have Node.js installed on your system.
-
Clone the repository:
git clone https://github.com/webtorrent/webtorrent-desktop.git
- Navigate to the project directory:
cd webtorrent-desktop
- Install dependencies:
npm install
Basic Usage
Running the Application
To start WebTorrent Desktop, run the following command:
npm start
Adding a Torrent
- Click the "+" button in the top-left corner of the application.
- Enter a magnet link or select a .torrent file from your computer.
- WebTorrent Desktop will begin downloading the torrent.
Streaming a Video
To stream a video file from a torrent:
- Select the torrent from the list.
- Click on the video file you want to stream.
- The built-in video player will open and start playing the file.
Development
To run the application in development mode with hot reloading:
npm run dev
This will start the application and automatically reload it when you make changes to the source code.
Top Related Projects
Deluge BitTorrent client - Git mirror, PRs only
Pros of Deluge
- Highly customizable with a plugin system
- Supports both desktop and web-based interfaces
- Lightweight and efficient resource usage
Cons of Deluge
- Less user-friendly interface compared to qBittorrent and WebTorrent Desktop
- Slower development cycle and less frequent updates
Code Comparison
Deluge
class Core(component.Component):
def __init__(self, config):
component.Component.__init__(self, "Core")
self.config = config
qBittorrent
class Application : public QApplication
{
Q_OBJECT
public:
Application(int &argc, char **argv);
};
WebTorrent Desktop
const WebTorrent = require('webtorrent')
const client = new WebTorrent()
client.add(torrentId, (torrent) => {
// Torrents can contain many files. Let's use the .mp4 file
const file = torrent.files.find(function (file) {
return file.name.endsWith('.mp4')
})
})
The code snippets showcase different programming languages and approaches:
- Deluge uses Python with a component-based architecture
- qBittorrent is built with C++ and Qt framework
- WebTorrent Desktop utilizes JavaScript and Node.js
Each project has its strengths, with Deluge offering flexibility, qBittorrent providing a robust desktop experience, and WebTorrent Desktop focusing on web technologies for torrent streaming.
Official Transmission BitTorrent client repository
Pros of Transmission
- Lightweight and efficient, consuming fewer system resources
- Cross-platform support (Linux, macOS, Windows)
- Simple and intuitive user interface
Cons of Transmission
- Fewer advanced features compared to qBittorrent
- Limited customization options
- Slower development cycle and less frequent updates
Code Comparison
Transmission (C):
static void
tr_peerMgrAddIncoming(tr_peerMgr* manager, tr_address const* addr, tr_port port, struct peer_atom** atom)
{
assert(tr_isAddress(addr));
tr_peerMgrLock(manager);
*atom = getExistingAtom(manager, addr, port);
tr_peerMgrUnlock(manager);
}
qBittorrent (C++):
void Session::addTorrent(const QString& source, const AddTorrentParams ¶ms)
{
if (Net::DownloadManager::hasSupportedScheme(source))
m_downloadHandler->download(source, params);
else
addTorrent_impl(source, params);
}
WebTorrent Desktop (JavaScript):
function startServer (torrentSummary) {
const torrent = torrentSummary.torrentKey
? getTorrentByKey(torrentSummary.torrentKey)
: null
if (torrent && torrent.serverRunning) return
torrentSummary.serverRunning = true
const serverCallback = createTorrentServerCallback(torrentSummary)
const server = torrentSummary.server = new WebTorrent.Server(serverCallback)
return new Promise((resolve) => server.listen(0, () => resolve()))
}
qBittorrent BitTorrent client
Pros of qBittorrent
- Feature-rich and mature BitTorrent client with a wide range of functionalities
- Cross-platform support (Windows, macOS, Linux)
- Active development and regular updates
Cons of qBittorrent
- Steeper learning curve for new users compared to WebTorrent Desktop
- Larger application size and resource usage
Code Comparison
qBittorrent (C++):
void TorrentHandle::setAutoManaged(bool enable)
{
if (m_nativeStatus.auto_managed == enable) return;
m_nativeHandle.auto_managed(enable);
m_nativeStatus.auto_managed = enable;
}
WebTorrent Desktop (JavaScript):
function startTorrentingSummary (torrentSummary) {
const torrentKey = torrentSummary.torrentKey
// Don't start the torrent if it's already queued or downloading
if (torrentSummary.status !== 'paused') {
return
}
The code snippets showcase different approaches:
- qBittorrent uses C++ for lower-level control and performance
- WebTorrent Desktop utilizes JavaScript, making it more accessible for web developers
qBittorrent offers more advanced features and customization options, while WebTorrent Desktop provides a simpler, more user-friendly interface. qBittorrent is better suited for power users and those requiring extensive control over their torrenting experience, whereas WebTorrent Desktop caters to users seeking a straightforward, web-technology-based solution.
Full-featured BitTorrent client package and utilities
Pros of torrent
- Written in Go, offering good performance and cross-platform compatibility
- Lightweight library design, suitable for embedding in other applications
- Focuses on core BitTorrent functionality, allowing for flexible integration
Cons of torrent
- Lacks a full-featured GUI, unlike qBittorrent and WebTorrent Desktop
- May require more setup and configuration for end-users compared to ready-to-use clients
- Less extensive feature set for casual users (e.g., no built-in search or media player)
Code Comparison
torrent (Go):
client, err := torrent.NewClient(nil)
t, err := client.AddMagnet(magnetLink)
<-t.GotInfo()
t.DownloadAll()
qBittorrent (C++):
libtorrent::session ses;
libtorrent::add_torrent_params p;
p.url = magnetLink;
libtorrent::torrent_handle h = ses.add_torrent(p);
WebTorrent Desktop (JavaScript):
const client = new WebTorrent()
client.add(magnetLink, (torrent) => {
torrent.on('done', () => console.log('Download finished'))
})
The code snippets demonstrate the basic usage of each library for adding a magnet link and starting a download. torrent and qBittorrent use more traditional BitTorrent approaches, while WebTorrent Desktop leverages web technologies for its implementation.