Pros of react-datepicker

• More comprehensive feature set, including time selection and custom input components
• Larger community and more frequent updates (20k+ stars, regular releases)
• Extensive documentation and examples

Cons of react-datepicker

• Larger bundle size due to more features
• Steeper learning curve for basic implementations
• Less modern default styling compared to react-modern-calendar-datepicker

Code Comparison

react-datepicker:

import DatePicker from "react-datepicker";

<DatePicker
  selected={startDate}
  onChange={(date) => setStartDate(date)}
  showTimeSelect
  dateFormat="Pp"
/>

react-modern-calendar-datepicker:

import DatePicker from "react-modern-calendar-datepicker";

<DatePicker
  value={selectedDay}
  onChange={setSelectedDay}
  inputPlaceholder="Select a day"
/>

The code comparison shows that react-datepicker offers more built-in options like time selection, while react-modern-calendar-datepicker has a simpler API for basic date picking. react-datepicker uses a Date object for its value, whereas react-modern-calendar-datepicker uses a custom object structure.

Pros of react-dates

• More comprehensive and feature-rich, offering a wide range of customization options
• Better documentation and extensive examples for various use cases
• Larger community support and more frequent updates

Cons of react-dates

• Larger bundle size due to its extensive feature set
• Steeper learning curve for beginners due to its complexity
• Requires additional styling and configuration for a modern look

Code Comparison

react-dates:

import { DateRangePicker } from 'react-dates';

<DateRangePicker
  startDate={this.state.startDate}
  startDateId="start_date_id"
  endDate={this.state.endDate}
  endDateId="end_date_id"
  onDatesChange={({ startDate, endDate }) => this.setState({ startDate, endDate })}
  focusedInput={this.state.focusedInput}
  onFocusChange={focusedInput => this.setState({ focusedInput })}
/>

react-modern-calendar-datepicker:

import DatePicker from 'react-modern-calendar-datepicker';

<DatePicker
  value={selectedDay}
  onChange={setSelectedDay}
  inputPlaceholder="Select a day"
  shouldHighlightWeekends
/>

The react-dates example shows more complex configuration for a date range picker, while react-modern-calendar-datepicker offers a simpler API for a single date picker. react-dates requires more setup but provides greater flexibility, whereas react-modern-calendar-datepicker is more straightforward to implement but may have fewer customization options.

Pros of material-ui-pickers

• Integrated with Material-UI design system, providing consistent styling
• Offers a wider range of date/time picker components (e.g., time, date-time, month)
• Better accessibility support and keyboard navigation

Cons of material-ui-pickers

• Larger bundle size due to Material-UI dependencies
• Less customizable in terms of styling and layout
• Steeper learning curve for developers not familiar with Material-UI

Code Comparison

react-modern-calendar-datepicker:

import DatePicker from 'react-modern-calendar-datepicker';

<DatePicker
  value={selectedDay}
  onChange={setSelectedDay}
  inputPlaceholder="Select a day"
/>

material-ui-pickers:

import { DatePicker } from '@material-ui/pickers';

<DatePicker
  value={selectedDate}
  onChange={handleDateChange}
  label="Select a date"
/>

Both libraries offer simple APIs for basic date picking functionality. However, material-ui-pickers provides more options for customization and integration with Material-UI components, while react-modern-calendar-datepicker focuses on a lightweight and standalone solution.

Pros of react-day-picker

• More customizable and flexible, allowing for advanced use cases
• Extensive documentation and examples
• Larger community and more frequent updates

Cons of react-day-picker

• Steeper learning curve due to its flexibility
• Requires more setup for basic use cases

Code Comparison

react-day-picker:

import { DayPicker } from 'react-day-picker';

function MyDatePicker() {
  return <DayPicker mode="single" />;
}

react-modern-calendar-datepicker:

import DatePicker from 'react-modern-calendar-datepicker';

function MyDatePicker() {
  return <DatePicker />;
}

Summary

react-day-picker offers more flexibility and customization options, making it suitable for complex date-picking scenarios. It has a larger community and more frequent updates. However, it may require more setup for basic use cases and has a steeper learning curve.

react-modern-calendar-datepicker provides a simpler API and is easier to set up for basic date-picking needs. It may be more suitable for projects that don't require extensive customization.

The code comparison shows that both libraries offer a straightforward implementation for basic date picking, with react-modern-calendar-datepicker requiring slightly less code for a default setup.

Pros of calendar

• More comprehensive and feature-rich, offering a wider range of calendar-related functionalities
• Better documentation and examples, making it easier for developers to implement and customize
• Larger community and more frequent updates, ensuring better long-term support and maintenance

Cons of calendar

• Steeper learning curve due to its extensive feature set and configuration options
• Larger bundle size, which may impact performance for simpler use cases
• Less focused on modern design aesthetics compared to react-modern-calendar-datepicker

Code Comparison

react-modern-calendar-datepicker:

<Calendar
  value={selectedDay}
  onChange={setSelectedDay}
  shouldHighlightWeekends
/>

calendar:

<Calendar
  value={value}
  onSelect={onSelect}
  onPanelChange={onPanelChange}
  fullscreen={false}
  headerRender={({ value, type, onChange, onTypeChange }) => {
    // Custom header rendering
  }}
/>

The code comparison shows that calendar offers more customization options and flexibility in its implementation, while react-modern-calendar-datepicker provides a simpler and more straightforward approach for basic date picking functionality.