Pros of laravel-medialibrary

• More comprehensive media management solution with advanced features like image manipulation and conversions
• Better integration with Laravel's Eloquent ORM for associating media with models
• Extensive documentation and active community support

Cons of laravel-medialibrary

• Steeper learning curve due to its more complex architecture
• May be overkill for simple file management needs
• Less focus on front-end file browsing and management interface

Code Comparison

laravel-medialibrary:

$model->addMedia($pathToFile)->toMediaCollection('images');
$model->getMedia('images')->first()->getUrl('thumb');

laravel-file-manager:

$fileManager = new FileManager();
$fileManager->upload($request->file('file'), 'uploads');

The laravel-medialibrary code demonstrates its tight integration with Eloquent models and built-in image conversion capabilities. In contrast, laravel-file-manager offers a simpler API for basic file operations without model associations.

laravel-medialibrary is better suited for projects requiring advanced media handling and model relationships, while laravel-file-manager is more appropriate for straightforward file management tasks with a focus on user interface.

Pros of laravel-filemanager

• More extensive documentation and examples
• Supports image editing features (cropping, resizing)
• Includes a built-in media selector for TinyMCE and CKEditor

Cons of laravel-filemanager

• Less frequent updates and maintenance
• More complex setup process
• Limited customization options for the user interface

Code Comparison

laravel-filemanager:

$config = [
    'use_package_routes' => true,
    'allow_private_folder' => true,
    'base_directory' => 'public',
];

laravel-file-manager:

$config = [
    'leftDisk' => 'public',
    'rightDisk' => 'public',
    'leftPath' => '/',
    'rightPath' => '/',
    'separateMultipleUploads' => true,
];

Both packages offer file management capabilities for Laravel applications, but they differ in their approach and feature sets. laravel-filemanager provides more out-of-the-box features for media management and editor integration, while laravel-file-manager focuses on a simpler, more customizable approach with a modern user interface. The code comparison shows differences in configuration options, reflecting their distinct approaches to file management.