Pros of Blueprint

• Comprehensive UI toolkit with a wide range of components
• Consistent design system for building complex applications
• Extensive documentation and examples

Cons of Blueprint

• Steeper learning curve due to its extensive feature set
• Larger bundle size compared to more focused libraries
• May be overkill for simpler projects or single-component needs

Code Comparison

React Modal:

import ReactModal from 'react-modal';

<ReactModal
  isOpen={modalIsOpen}
  onRequestClose={closeModal}
  contentLabel="Example Modal"
>
  <h2>Modal Content</h2>
</ReactModal>

Blueprint:

import { Dialog, Classes } from "@blueprintjs/core";

<Dialog
  isOpen={isOpen}
  onClose={handleClose}
  title="Dialog Title"
>
  <div className={Classes.DIALOG_BODY}>
    <p>Dialog content</p>
  </div>
</Dialog>

React Modal is a focused library for creating modal dialogs, while Blueprint provides a comprehensive set of UI components, including modals. React Modal offers simplicity and ease of use for projects that only need modal functionality. Blueprint, on the other hand, provides a consistent design system and a wide range of components, making it suitable for larger, more complex applications. However, Blueprint's extensive feature set may result in a larger bundle size and a steeper learning curve compared to React Modal's more focused approach.

Pros of Material-UI

• Comprehensive UI component library with a wide range of pre-built components
• Consistent design language following Material Design principles
• Extensive customization options and theming support

Cons of Material-UI

• Larger bundle size due to the extensive component library
• Steeper learning curve for developers new to Material Design concepts
• More opinionated styling approach, which may not suit all project requirements

Code Comparison

Material-UI modal implementation:

import { Modal, Box } from '@mui/material';

<Modal open={open} onClose={handleClose}>
  <Box sx={modalStyle}>
    <h2>Modal Title</h2>
    <p>Modal content goes here</p>
  </Box>
</Modal>

React Modal implementation:

import Modal from 'react-modal';

<Modal isOpen={open} onRequestClose={handleClose}>
  <h2>Modal Title</h2>
  <p>Modal content goes here</p>
</Modal>

Summary

Material-UI offers a comprehensive UI library with consistent design and extensive customization options, but comes with a larger bundle size and steeper learning curve. React Modal is a lightweight, focused solution for modal functionality, providing more flexibility in styling but requiring additional work for complex UI components.

Pros of react-bootstrap

• Comprehensive UI component library with a wide range of pre-built components
• Consistent styling and theming based on Bootstrap
• Active community and regular updates

Cons of react-bootstrap

• Larger bundle size due to the extensive component library
• Less flexibility for custom designs compared to individual modal solutions

Code Comparison

react-bootstrap modal example:

import { Modal, Button } from 'react-bootstrap';

function MyModal({ show, handleClose }) {
  return (
    <Modal show={show} onHide={handleClose}>
      <Modal.Header closeButton>
        <Modal.Title>Modal Title</Modal.Title>
      </Modal.Header>
      <Modal.Body>Modal content goes here</Modal.Body>
      <Modal.Footer>
        <Button variant="secondary" onClick={handleClose}>Close</Button>
      </Modal.Footer>
    </Modal>
  );
}

react-modal example:

import Modal from 'react-modal';

function MyModal({ isOpen, onRequestClose }) {
  return (
    <Modal isOpen={isOpen} onRequestClose={onRequestClose}>
      <h2>Modal Title</h2>
      <p>Modal content goes here</p>
      <button onClick={onRequestClose}>Close</button>
    </Modal>
  );
}

Summary

react-bootstrap offers a comprehensive UI library with consistent styling, while react-modal provides a focused solution for modal functionality. Choose react-bootstrap for a full-featured Bootstrap-based design system, or react-modal for a lightweight, customizable modal implementation.

Pros of Ant Design

• Comprehensive UI component library with a wide range of components beyond just modals
• Consistent design language and theming capabilities
• Active development and large community support

Cons of Ant Design

• Larger bundle size due to its extensive component set
• Steeper learning curve for developers new to the library
• Less flexibility for customizing individual components

Code Comparison

React Modal:

import ReactModal from 'react-modal';

<ReactModal
  isOpen={modalIsOpen}
  onRequestClose={closeModal}
  contentLabel="Example Modal"
>
  <h2>Modal Content</h2>
  <button onClick={closeModal}>Close</button>
</ReactModal>

Ant Design:

import { Modal } from 'antd';

<Modal
  title="Modal Title"
  visible={isModalVisible}
  onOk={handleOk}
  onCancel={handleCancel}
>
  <p>Modal Content</p>
</Modal>

Summary

React Modal is a focused library for creating accessible modal dialogs in React applications. It offers simplicity and ease of use for developers who only need modal functionality.

Ant Design, on the other hand, is a comprehensive UI library that includes a modal component along with many other UI elements. It provides a consistent design system but may be overkill for projects that only require modal functionality.

Choose React Modal for lightweight, modal-specific needs, and Ant Design for larger projects requiring a complete UI toolkit with consistent design.

Pros of Headless UI

• More comprehensive UI component library, offering various accessible components beyond just modals
• Unstyled components provide greater flexibility for custom designs
• Seamless integration with Tailwind CSS for rapid development

Cons of Headless UI

• Steeper learning curve due to its headless nature and more complex API
• Requires more setup and configuration compared to React Modal's simpler implementation

Code Comparison

React Modal:

import ReactModal from 'react-modal';

<ReactModal isOpen={isOpen} onRequestClose={closeModal}>
  <h2>Modal Content</h2>
  <button onClick={closeModal}>Close</button>
</ReactModal>

Headless UI:

import { Dialog } from '@headlessui/react'

<Dialog open={isOpen} onClose={closeModal}>
  <Dialog.Overlay className="fixed inset-0 bg-black opacity-30" />
  <Dialog.Title>Modal Content</Dialog.Title>
  <button onClick={closeModal}>Close</button>
</Dialog>

Summary

Headless UI offers a more comprehensive and flexible solution for building accessible UI components, including modals. It provides greater customization options and integrates well with Tailwind CSS. However, it may require more setup and has a steeper learning curve compared to React Modal's simpler, focused approach to modal functionality.