Pros of strap

• More customizable with user-specific dotfiles and Brewfile support
• Includes additional features like disk encryption check and Xcode CLI tools installation
• Actively maintained with recent updates

Cons of strap

• Less opinionated, requiring more user configuration
• May require more setup time for new users
• Focused primarily on macOS, less portable to other systems

Code comparison

strap:

#!/bin/bash
set -e

# Check if we need to ask for sudo password
sudo -v

# Keep-alive: update existing `sudo` time stamp until `.macos` has finished
while true; do sudo -n true; sleep 60; kill -0 "$$" || exit; done 2>/dev/null &

laptop:

#!/bin/bash
set -e

# Welcome to the thoughtbot laptop script!
# Be prepared to turn your laptop (or desktop, no haters here)
# into an awesome development machine.

fancy_echo() {
  local fmt="$1"; shift

Summary

strap offers more customization and macOS-specific features, while laptop provides a more opinionated, cross-platform setup. strap may require more initial configuration but allows for greater flexibility. laptop offers a simpler out-of-the-box experience but with less room for customization. Both scripts aim to automate development environment setup, with strap focusing on macOS and laptop being more platform-agnostic.

Pros of brew

• Broader package management system for macOS and Linux
• Larger community and more extensive package repository
• Regularly updated and maintained by a dedicated team

Cons of brew

• More complex setup and usage for beginners
• Can potentially conflict with system-installed packages
• Requires more manual configuration for development environments

Code Comparison

laptop:

#!/bin/bash

fancy_echo() {
  local fmt="$1"; shift
  printf "\\n$fmt\\n" "$@"
}

brew:

module Homebrew
  module_function

  def install
    raise FormulaUnspecifiedError if ARGV.named.empty?
    ARGV.resolved_formulae.each do |f|
      install_formula(f)
    end
  end
end

Summary

laptop is a focused script for setting up development environments on macOS, while brew is a comprehensive package manager. laptop offers a simpler, opinionated setup process, whereas brew provides more flexibility and a wider range of packages. The choice between them depends on the user's needs and experience level.

Pros of dotfiles

• More comprehensive and customizable setup, including various dotfiles and configurations
• Includes browser-specific settings and extensions for web developers
• Offers a wider range of tools and utilities beyond basic development setup

Cons of dotfiles

• Potentially overwhelming for beginners due to its extensive customizations
• May require more manual intervention and tweaking to suit individual needs
• Less focused on providing a standardized development environment across teams

Code Comparison

laptop:

#!/bin/sh

fancy_echo() {
  local fmt="$1"; shift
  printf "\\n$fmt\\n" "$@"
}

dotfiles:

#!/bin/bash

# Colors
ESC_SEQ="\x1b["
COL_RESET=$ESC_SEQ"39;49;00m"
COL_RED=$ESC_SEQ"31;01m"
COL_GREEN=$ESC_SEQ"32;01m"
COL_YELLOW=$ESC_SEQ"33;01m"

Summary

laptop focuses on providing a streamlined, opinionated setup for development environments, particularly suited for Ruby and web development. It's designed to be easily adoptable across teams.

dotfiles offers a more personalized and extensive configuration, catering to web developers with a broader set of tools and customizations. It provides a richer set of dotfiles and configurations but may require more effort to tailor to individual needs.

Pros of dev-setup

• More comprehensive setup, including data science and machine learning tools
• Detailed documentation and explanations for each component
• Supports both macOS and Ubuntu

Cons of dev-setup

• Less frequently updated compared to laptop
• More complex setup process due to its extensive coverage
• May include unnecessary tools for some users

Code Comparison

laptop:

#!/bin/bash

fancy_echo() {
  local fmt="$1"; shift
  printf "\\n$fmt\\n" "$@"
}

dev-setup:

#!/usr/bin/env python

import subprocess

def run_command(command):
    process = subprocess.Popen(command, shell=True, stdout=subprocess.PIPE, stderr=subprocess.STDOUT)
    output = process.communicate()[0].decode('utf-8')
    return output

laptop focuses on a simple Bash script for setup, while dev-setup uses Python for more complex operations and cross-platform compatibility. laptop's approach is more straightforward and easier to maintain, but dev-setup offers more flexibility and power for handling diverse setups across different operating systems.

Both projects aim to automate development environment setup, but they cater to different user needs. laptop is ideal for those seeking a quick, opinionated setup for Ruby and web development, while dev-setup is better suited for users requiring a more extensive toolkit, especially in data science and machine learning fields.