Pros of react-datepicker

• More comprehensive feature set, including time selection and range selection
• Highly customizable appearance and behavior
• Larger community and more frequent updates

Cons of react-datepicker

• Larger bundle size due to more features
• Steeper learning curve for advanced customizations

Code Comparison

react-datepicker:

import DatePicker from "react-datepicker";

<DatePicker
  selected={startDate}
  onChange={(date) => setStartDate(date)}
  showTimeSelect
  dateFormat="Pp"
/>

react-date-picker:

import DatePicker from "react-date-picker";

<DatePicker
  onChange={setDate}
  value={date}
/>

react-datepicker offers more built-in options like time selection and custom date formatting, while react-date-picker provides a simpler API for basic date picking functionality.

react-datepicker is generally more feature-rich and flexible, but this comes at the cost of a larger bundle size and potentially more complex setup for advanced use cases. react-date-picker, on the other hand, offers a more straightforward implementation for basic date picking needs, with a smaller footprint and simpler API.

The choice between these libraries depends on the specific requirements of your project, such as the need for advanced features, customization options, and bundle size considerations.

Pros of react-dates

• More comprehensive date range selection functionality
• Highly customizable with extensive theming options
• Better support for internationalization and localization

Cons of react-dates

• Larger bundle size and more dependencies
• Steeper learning curve due to more complex API
• Less frequent updates and maintenance

Code Comparison

react-dates:

import { DateRangePicker } from 'react-dates';

<DateRangePicker
  startDate={this.state.startDate}
  startDateId="start_date_id"
  endDate={this.state.endDate}
  endDateId="end_date_id"
  onDatesChange={({ startDate, endDate }) => this.setState({ startDate, endDate })}
  focusedInput={this.state.focusedInput}
  onFocusChange={focusedInput => this.setState({ focusedInput })}
/>

react-date-picker:

import DatePicker from 'react-date-picker';

<DatePicker
  onChange={this.onChange}
  value={this.state.date}
/>

The code comparison shows that react-dates requires more configuration for a date range picker, while react-date-picker offers a simpler API for single date selection. react-dates provides more flexibility but at the cost of increased complexity, whereas react-date-picker focuses on simplicity and ease of use for basic date picking functionality.

Pros of material-ui-pickers

• Integrated with Material-UI design system, providing consistent styling
• Offers a wider range of date/time picker components (e.g., date, time, datetime)
• Better support for internationalization and localization

Cons of material-ui-pickers

• Larger bundle size due to Material-UI dependencies
• Steeper learning curve for developers not familiar with Material-UI
• Less flexibility for custom styling outside of Material-UI theming

Code Comparison

react-date-picker:

import DatePicker from 'react-date-picker';

function MyApp() {
  const [value, onChange] = useState(new Date());
  return <DatePicker onChange={onChange} value={value} />;
}

material-ui-pickers:

import { DatePicker } from '@material-ui/pickers';

function MyApp() {
  const [selectedDate, handleDateChange] = useState(new Date());
  return <DatePicker value={selectedDate} onChange={handleDateChange} />;
}

Both libraries offer similar basic functionality, but material-ui-pickers provides a more comprehensive set of components and better integration with Material-UI. react-date-picker is lighter and more focused on providing a simple date picker component, while material-ui-pickers offers a broader range of date and time selection tools within the Material-UI ecosystem.

Pros of calendar

• More comprehensive calendar functionality, including support for various calendar systems (e.g., Gregorian, Chinese, Islamic)
• Greater customization options for styling and layout
• Extensive API for advanced use cases and integration with other components

Cons of calendar

• Steeper learning curve due to more complex API and configuration options
• Larger bundle size, which may impact performance for simpler use cases
• Less focused on date picking specifically, requiring more setup for basic date selection

Code Comparison

react-date-picker:

import DatePicker from 'react-date-picker';

function MyApp() {
  const [value, onChange] = useState(new Date());
  return <DatePicker onChange={onChange} value={value} />;
}

calendar:

import Calendar from 'rc-calendar';

function MyApp() {
  const [value, setValue] = useState(moment());
  return (
    <Calendar
      value={value}
      onSelect={(date) => setValue(date)}
      fullscreen={false}
    />
  );
}

The react-date-picker example shows a simpler implementation for basic date picking, while the calendar example demonstrates more configuration options but requires additional setup.

Pros of react-day-picker

• More customizable and flexible, allowing for complex date selection scenarios
• Extensive documentation and examples, making it easier to implement various use cases
• Supports multiple languages and localization out of the box

Cons of react-day-picker

• Larger bundle size, which may impact performance in some applications
• Steeper learning curve due to its extensive API and configuration options

Code Comparison

react-day-picker:

import { DayPicker } from 'react-day-picker';

function MyDatePicker() {
  return <DayPicker mode="single" />;
}

react-date-picker:

import DatePicker from 'react-date-picker';

function MyDatePicker() {
  return <DatePicker onChange={onChange} value={value} />;
}

Both libraries offer simple implementation for basic date picking functionality. However, react-day-picker provides more options for customization and complex scenarios, while react-date-picker focuses on a straightforward, lightweight approach.

react-day-picker is better suited for projects requiring advanced date selection features and extensive customization. On the other hand, react-date-picker is ideal for simpler use cases and projects where minimizing bundle size is a priority.