Pros of android-floating-action-button

• Identical functionality and features
• Same implementation and codebase
• Consistent user experience across both repositories

Cons of android-floating-action-button

• No unique advantages over the other repository
• Potential confusion due to duplicate repositories
• Redundant maintenance efforts

Code Comparison

Both repositories contain identical code, so there are no differences to highlight. Here's a sample of the shared code:

public class FloatingActionButton extends ImageButton {
    private static final int SHADOW_HORIZ_OFFSET_DEFAULT = 0;
    private static final int SHADOW_VERT_OFFSET_DEFAULT = 0;
    private static final int SHADOW_RADIUS_DEFAULT = 4;
    private static final int SHADOW_COLOR_DEFAULT = 0x66000000;
    // ... (rest of the code is identical)
}

Summary

The comparison between android-floating-action-button and android-floating-action-button reveals that they are essentially the same repository. Both provide a floating action button implementation for Android applications with identical features, codebase, and user experience. The main drawback is the redundancy of having two identical repositories, which may lead to confusion and unnecessary maintenance efforts. Users can choose either repository interchangeably without any functional differences.

Pros of faboptions

• More customizable with additional animation options
• Supports multiple FAB options in a single component
• Easier integration with modern Android development practices

Cons of faboptions

• Less mature and potentially less stable than android-floating-action-button
• Fewer stars and contributors, indicating a smaller community
• May have limited documentation and support compared to the Zendesk project

Code Comparison

faboptions:

val fabOptions = findViewById<FabOptions>(R.id.fab_options)
fabOptions.setButtonsMenu(R.menu.menu_fab_options)
fabOptions.setOnClickListener { view ->
    when (view.id) {
        R.id.faboptions_favorite -> // Handle favorite action
        R.id.faboptions_textsms -> // Handle textsms action
        R.id.faboptions_download -> // Handle download action
    }
}

android-floating-action-button:

FloatingActionButton fab = (FloatingActionButton) findViewById(R.id.fab);
fab.setIcon(R.drawable.ic_fab_star);
fab.setColorNormalResId(R.color.pink);
fab.setColorPressedResId(R.color.pink_pressed);
fab.setOnClickListener(view -> // Handle click action);

The faboptions library offers a more concise way to handle multiple FAB options, while android-floating-action-button provides a simpler approach for single FAB implementations. faboptions uses Kotlin, which aligns with modern Android development trends, whereas android-floating-action-button uses Java.