Pros of NeteaseCloudMusicFlac

• Focuses specifically on downloading high-quality FLAC files
• Simpler and more straightforward for users who only want FLAC downloads
• Potentially faster for bulk FLAC downloads due to specialized functionality

Cons of NeteaseCloudMusicFlac

• Limited functionality compared to musicbox's broader feature set
• Less actively maintained, with fewer recent updates
• Lacks the command-line interface and playback features of musicbox

Code Comparison

NeteaseCloudMusicFlac:

def get_songurls(song_ids):
    return (
        'http://music.163.com/api/song/enhance/player/url?id={0}&ids=[{0}]&br=320000'.format(i)
        for i in song_ids
    )

musicbox:

def get_song_url(song_id, quality):
    url = 'http://music.163.com/api/song/enhance/player/url?ids=[{0}]&br={1}'.format(
        song_id, quality
    )
    return url

Both projects use similar API endpoints for retrieving song URLs, but musicbox's implementation is more flexible with a quality parameter. NeteaseCloudMusicFlac focuses on high-quality downloads, while musicbox offers more versatility in its functionality.

Pros of music-dl

• Supports multiple music platforms (NetEase, QQ Music, Kugou, Kuwo, etc.)
• Command-line interface for easy batch downloading
• Actively maintained with recent updates

Cons of music-dl

• Lacks a graphical user interface
• Does not offer streaming functionality
• Limited to downloading functionality only

Code Comparison

music-dl:

def download_song(self, song):
    url = self.get_song_url(song)
    filename = self.get_filename(song)
    self.download_file(url, filename)

musicbox:

def play_song(self, song):
    url = self.get_song_url(song)
    player = Player()
    player.play(url)

Key Differences

musicbox is a more comprehensive NetEase Cloud Music client with features like playlist management, streaming, and a text-based user interface. It focuses on providing a complete music listening experience within the terminal.

music-dl, on the other hand, is primarily a downloader that supports multiple platforms. It's designed for users who want to quickly download music from various sources using a simple command-line interface.

While musicbox offers a richer feature set for NetEase Cloud Music users, music-dl provides broader platform support and is more suitable for those who prefer to download and manage their music files locally.

Pros of music

• Web-based interface, making it more accessible across devices
• Supports multiple music platforms (QQ Music, Netease, Xiami, etc.)
• More recent updates and active development

Cons of music

• Less comprehensive command-line functionality
• May require more setup for server deployment
• Potentially higher resource usage due to web interface

Code Comparison

musicbox (Python):

def play(self, song, volume=5):
    self.playing_flag = True
    self.process = subprocess.Popen(['mpg123', '-R', '-f', str(volume * 1000), song.get('mp3url')], stdin=subprocess.PIPE, stdout=subprocess.PIPE, stderr=subprocess.PIPE)
    self.process.stdin.write(b'V ' + str(volume).encode() + b'\n')
    self.process.stdin.flush()

music (PHP):

public function search($query, $page = 1)
{
    $result = [];
    foreach ($this->site as $key => $site) {
        $result[$key] = $site->search($query, $page);
    }
    return $result;
}

Summary

musicbox is a command-line based music player with a focus on simplicity and efficiency, while music offers a web-based interface supporting multiple music platforms. musicbox may be preferred for users who prioritize command-line functionality, while music provides a more user-friendly experience for those comfortable with web interfaces. The choice between the two depends on individual preferences and use cases.

Pros of Listen1 Chrome Extension

• Cross-platform compatibility as a browser extension
• User-friendly interface with a modern design
• Supports multiple music streaming services in one place

Cons of Listen1 Chrome Extension

• Limited to browser usage, not a standalone application
• Potentially affected by changes in browser extension policies
• May have performance limitations compared to native applications

Code Comparison

MusicBox (Python):

def login(self, username, password):
    pattern = re.compile(r'^0\d{2,3}\d{7,8}$|^1[34578]\d{9}$')
    if pattern.match(username):
        return self.phone_login(username, password)
    action = 'https://music.163.com/weapi/login/'
    text = {
        'username': username,
        'password': password,
        'rememberLogin': 'true'
    }
    data = encrypted_request(text)
    try:
        return self.httpRequest('POST', action, data)
    except requests.exceptions.RequestException as e:
        log.error(e)
        return {'code': 501}

Listen1 Chrome Extension (JavaScript):

function getParameterByName(name, url) {
  if (!url) url = window.location.href;
  name = name.replace(/[\[\]]/g, '\\$&');
  var regex = new RegExp('[?&]' + name + '(=([^&#]*)|&|#|$)'),
      results = regex.exec(url);
  if (!results) return null;
  if (!results[2]) return '';
  return decodeURIComponent(results[2].replace(/\+/g, ' '));
}

The code snippets show different approaches: MusicBox focuses on login functionality, while Listen1 Chrome Extension demonstrates URL parameter parsing. This reflects their distinct architectures and purposes.

Pros of YesPlayMusic

• Modern and visually appealing user interface
• Cross-platform support (Windows, macOS, Linux)
• Built with Vue.js, offering a responsive and interactive experience

Cons of YesPlayMusic

• Larger application size due to Electron framework
• May have higher resource usage compared to command-line interface
• Potentially slower startup time

Code Comparison

MusicBox (Python):

def login(username, password):
    pattern = re.compile(r'^0\d{2,3}\d{7,8}$|^1[34578]\d{9}$')
    if pattern.match(username):
        return login_phone(username, password)
    action = 'login'
    return auth.login(action, username, password)

YesPlayMusic (JavaScript):

async login(params) {
  const res = await loginAccount(params);
  if (res.code === 200) {
    this.handleLoginSuccess(res);
  }
  return res;
}

Summary

MusicBox is a command-line interface music player for NetEase Cloud Music, written in Python. It offers a lightweight solution for playing music from the terminal.

YesPlayMusic is a modern, cross-platform desktop music player for NetEase Cloud Music, built with Vue.js and Electron. It provides a graphical user interface with a sleek design and enhanced user experience.

While MusicBox is more resource-efficient and faster to start up, YesPlayMusic offers a more visually appealing and user-friendly experience across multiple platforms. The choice between the two depends on user preferences for CLI vs GUI and system resources availability.