Pros of datetimepicker

• Native implementation for both iOS and Android, providing a more platform-specific look and feel
• Lightweight and performant, as it uses native components
• Offers more customization options for appearance and behavior

Cons of datetimepicker

• Requires more setup and configuration, especially for Android
• Less consistent cross-platform appearance, which may not be ideal for some apps
• Modal functionality needs to be implemented separately if desired

Code Comparison

react-native-modal-datetime-picker:

<DateTimePickerModal
  isVisible={isDatePickerVisible}
  mode="date"
  onConfirm={handleConfirm}
  onCancel={hideDatePicker}
/>

datetimepicker:

{showPicker && (
  <DateTimePicker
    value={date}
    mode="date"
    display="default"
    onChange={onChange}
  />
)}

The react-native-modal-datetime-picker provides a simpler API with built-in modal functionality, while datetimepicker requires manual handling of visibility and platform-specific implementations.

react-native-modal-datetime-picker offers a more streamlined, cross-platform consistent experience out of the box, making it easier to implement for developers who prioritize quick setup and uniform appearance across platforms. However, datetimepicker provides more native feel and potentially better performance, at the cost of additional setup and platform-specific considerations.

Pros of react-native-date-picker

• Offers a native date picker for both iOS and Android
• Supports a wide range of customization options, including custom styles and localization
• Provides time-only and datetime picker modes in addition to date-only

Cons of react-native-date-picker

• Requires manual modal implementation if a modal presentation is desired
• May have a steeper learning curve due to more configuration options
• Less focused on providing a pre-styled, ready-to-use modal solution

Code Comparison

react-native-modal-datetime-picker:

<DateTimePickerModal
  isVisible={isDatePickerVisible}
  mode="date"
  onConfirm={handleConfirm}
  onCancel={hideDatePicker}
/>

react-native-date-picker:

<DatePicker
  date={date}
  onDateChange={setDate}
  mode="date"
/>

The react-native-modal-datetime-picker provides a modal wrapper out of the box, while react-native-date-picker requires manual modal implementation if desired. react-native-date-picker offers more granular control over the picker's appearance and behavior, but may require more setup code for advanced use cases.

Both libraries are actively maintained and have good community support. The choice between them depends on whether you prefer a pre-packaged modal solution or more flexibility in implementation and styling.

Pros of react-native-calendars

• Offers a wide range of calendar components (day calendar, week calendar, agenda view)
• Highly customizable with extensive theming options
• Supports both iOS and Android platforms

Cons of react-native-calendars

• Larger package size due to more features and components
• Steeper learning curve for complex customizations
• May require additional setup for certain advanced features

Code Comparison

react-native-calendars:

import {Calendar} from 'react-native-calendars';

<Calendar
  onDayPress={(day) => {console.log('selected day', day)}}
  markedDates={{
    '2023-05-16': {selected: true, marked: true, selectedColor: 'blue'}
  }}
/>

react-native-modal-datetime-picker:

import DateTimePickerModal from "react-native-modal-datetime-picker";

<DateTimePickerModal
  isVisible={isDatePickerVisible}
  mode="date"
  onConfirm={handleConfirm}
  onCancel={hideDatePicker}
/>

The react-native-calendars library provides a more comprehensive calendar view with built-in styling options, while react-native-modal-datetime-picker focuses on a modal-based date and time selection. The choice between the two depends on the specific requirements of your project, such as the need for a full calendar view versus a simple date/time picker.

Pros of react-native-datepicker

• More customizable appearance with various style props
• Supports both date and time selection in a single component
• Offers a range of format options for displaying selected dates

Cons of react-native-datepicker

• Less actively maintained, with fewer recent updates
• May have compatibility issues with newer React Native versions
• Limited modal functionality compared to react-native-modal-datetime-picker

Code Comparison

react-native-datepicker:

<DatePicker
  style={{width: 200}}
  date={this.state.date}
  mode="date"
  placeholder="Select date"
  format="YYYY-MM-DD"
  confirmBtnText="Confirm"
  cancelBtnText="Cancel"
  onDateChange={(date) => {this.setState({date: date})}}
/>

react-native-modal-datetime-picker:

<DateTimePickerModal
  isVisible={isDatePickerVisible}
  mode="date"
  onConfirm={handleConfirm}
  onCancel={hideDatePicker}
/>

The react-native-datepicker component offers more inline customization options, while react-native-modal-datetime-picker focuses on a modal-based approach with simpler props. The latter provides a more native feel on both iOS and Android platforms.

Pros of picker

• More lightweight and focused on general-purpose picking
• Offers a wider range of customization options for the picker UI
• Supports both iOS and Android with a single API

Cons of picker

• Lacks built-in modal functionality, requiring additional setup for modal display
• Does not provide specific date and time picking functionality out of the box
• May require more code to implement a datetime picker specifically

Code Comparison

react-native-modal-datetime-picker:

<DateTimePickerModal
  isVisible={isDatePickerVisible}
  mode="datetime"
  onConfirm={handleConfirm}
  onCancel={hideDatePicker}
/>

picker:

<Picker
  selectedValue={selectedValue}
  style={{ height: 50, width: 150 }}
  onValueChange={(itemValue, itemIndex) => setSelectedValue(itemValue)}
>
  <Picker.Item label="Option 1" value="option1" />
  <Picker.Item label="Option 2" value="option2" />
</Picker>

The react-native-modal-datetime-picker provides a more streamlined approach for datetime picking with built-in modal functionality. In contrast, picker offers a more versatile solution for various types of pickers but requires additional setup for datetime picking and modal display.

Pros of react-native-picker-select

• More versatile, allowing for custom picker options beyond just date and time
• Simpler implementation for basic selection needs
• Supports both iOS and Android with a consistent API

Cons of react-native-picker-select

• Less specialized for date and time picking, which may require additional configuration
• Doesn't provide built-in modal functionality, requiring separate implementation if needed

Code Comparison

react-native-picker-select:

import RNPickerSelect from 'react-native-picker-select';

<RNPickerSelect
  onValueChange={(value) => console.log(value)}
  items={[
    { label: 'Football', value: 'football' },
    { label: 'Baseball', value: 'baseball' },
    { label: 'Hockey', value: 'hockey' },
  ]}
/>

react-native-modal-datetime-picker:

import DateTimePickerModal from "react-native-modal-datetime-picker";

<DateTimePickerModal
  isVisible={isDatePickerVisible}
  mode="date"
  onConfirm={handleConfirm}
  onCancel={hideDatePicker}
/>

The code comparison shows that react-native-picker-select is more flexible for general selection purposes, while react-native-modal-datetime-picker is specifically designed for date and time picking with built-in modal functionality. The choice between these libraries depends on the specific requirements of your project, with react-native-picker-select being more suitable for general selection needs and react-native-modal-datetime-picker being optimal for date and time picking scenarios.