vim-one

Pros of onedark.vim

• More active development with frequent updates and bug fixes
• Broader language support for syntax highlighting
• Includes support for popular plugins like airline and lightline

Cons of onedark.vim

• Slightly more complex configuration options
• May have higher resource usage due to extensive feature set

Code Comparison

onedark.vim:

let g:onedark_color_overrides = {
\ "black": {"gui": "#2F343F", "cterm": "235", "cterm16": "0" },
\ "purple": { "gui": "#C678DD", "cterm": "170", "cterm16": "5" }
\}

vim-one:

let g:one_allow_italics = 1
colorscheme one
set background=dark

Key Differences

• vim-one is a more lightweight option with simpler configuration
• onedark.vim offers more customization options and plugin integrations
• vim-one provides both light and dark themes, while onedark.vim focuses on a dark theme
• onedark.vim has a larger user base and more frequent updates

Conclusion

Both themes offer attractive color schemes for Vim. onedark.vim is more feature-rich and actively maintained, while vim-one provides a simpler, lightweight alternative. Choose based on your specific needs for customization, plugin support, and preferred aesthetics.

Pros of onedark.nvim

• Written in Lua, offering better performance and integration with Neovim
• Provides more customization options and color variants
• Actively maintained with frequent updates

Cons of onedark.nvim

• Requires Neovim 0.5 or later, limiting compatibility with older Vim versions
• May have a steeper learning curve for users unfamiliar with Lua configuration

Code Comparison

vim-one:

colorscheme one
set background=dark

onedark.nvim:

require('onedark').setup {
    style = 'dark',
    transparent = true,
    term_colors = true,
    -- More customization options available
}
require('onedark').load()

Summary

onedark.nvim is a modern, Lua-based implementation of the OneDark theme specifically designed for Neovim. It offers enhanced performance and extensive customization options compared to vim-one. However, it requires Neovim 0.5+ and may be less accessible for users more comfortable with traditional Vim script configurations.

vim-one is a more traditional Vim color scheme that works across both Vim and Neovim. It's simpler to set up and use, especially for those familiar with Vim scripting, but lacks some of the advanced features and customization options offered by onedark.nvim.

Choose onedark.nvim for a feature-rich, performant theme in Neovim, or vim-one for broader compatibility and simplicity across Vim and Neovim environments.

Pros of OneDark-Pro

• More comprehensive theme with support for multiple editors and IDEs
• Regularly updated with new features and improvements
• Larger community and user base, leading to more feedback and refinements

Cons of OneDark-Pro

• May be overwhelming for users who prefer a simpler, more focused theme
• Potentially higher resource usage due to its extensive feature set
• Learning curve for customizing and utilizing all available options

Code Comparison

vim-one:

colorscheme one
set background=dark
let g:airline_theme='one'

OneDark-Pro:

{
  "workbench.colorTheme": "One Dark Pro",
  "oneDarkPro.bold": true,
  "oneDarkPro.vivid": true
}

Summary

vim-one is a lightweight Vim-specific color scheme, while OneDark-Pro is a more comprehensive theme with support for multiple editors. vim-one offers simplicity and ease of use, making it ideal for Vim purists. OneDark-Pro provides a richer feature set and broader compatibility, but may be more complex to set up and customize. The choice between the two depends on the user's specific needs, preferred editor, and desired level of customization.

Pros of ayu-vim

• Offers three distinct color schemes (light, mirage, dark) for different preferences and environments
• Provides better support for various plugins and language-specific syntax highlighting
• More actively maintained with recent updates and contributions

Cons of ayu-vim

• May have a steeper learning curve due to more configuration options
• Could be considered less minimalistic compared to vim-one's simpler approach
• Might require additional setup for full functionality across different Vim distributions

Code Comparison

ayu-vim:

let ayucolor="mirage"
colorscheme ayu

" Custom highlight groups
hi Normal guibg=NONE ctermbg=NONE
hi LineNr guibg=NONE ctermbg=NONE

vim-one:

set background=dark
colorscheme one

" Enable italics
let g:one_allow_italics = 1

Both themes offer easy customization, but ayu-vim provides more granular control over color schemes and highlight groups. vim-one focuses on a simpler setup with fewer options, which may be preferable for users seeking a more straightforward configuration.