naive-ui-admin

Pros of vue-element-admin

• More mature and widely adopted, with a larger community and ecosystem
• Extensive documentation and examples available
• Comprehensive set of pre-built components and features

Cons of vue-element-admin

• Based on Element UI, which may have a steeper learning curve
• Potentially heavier and more complex for simpler projects
• Less flexibility in terms of customization compared to Naive UI

Code Comparison

vue-element-admin:

<el-table
  :data="tableData"
  style="width: 100%"
  :row-class-name="tableRowClassName">
  <el-table-column prop="date" label="Date" width="180"></el-table-column>
  <el-table-column prop="name" label="Name" width="180"></el-table-column>
</el-table>

naive-ui-admin:

<n-data-table
  :columns="columns"
  :data="data"
  :pagination="pagination"
  :bordered="false"
/>

The code comparison shows that naive-ui-admin uses a more concise syntax for table components, while vue-element-admin offers more granular control over table structure. This reflects the overall design philosophy of each project, with naive-ui-admin focusing on simplicity and vue-element-admin providing more detailed customization options.

Pros of vue-vben-admin

• More comprehensive and feature-rich, offering a wider range of components and utilities
• Better documentation and examples, making it easier for developers to get started
• Stronger community support and more frequent updates

Cons of vue-vben-admin

• Steeper learning curve due to its complexity and extensive feature set
• Potentially heavier and slower performance compared to the lightweight naive-ui-admin
• May include unnecessary features for simpler projects, leading to bloat

Code Comparison

vue-vben-admin:

<template>
  <BasicTable @register="registerTable">
    <template #toolbar>
      <a-button type="primary" @click="handleCreate">Create</a-button>
    </template>
  </BasicTable>
</template>

<script>
import { BasicTable } from '/@/components/Table';
import { useTable } from '/@/components/Table';
</script>

naive-ui-admin:

<template>
  <n-data-table :columns="columns" :data="data" :pagination="pagination" />
</template>

<script>
import { NDataTable } from 'naive-ui';
</script>

The code comparison shows that vue-vben-admin uses a more abstracted and feature-rich table component, while naive-ui-admin opts for a simpler, more straightforward approach. This reflects the overall difference in complexity and feature set between the two admin templates.

Pros of vue-admin-better

• More comprehensive documentation and examples
• Larger community and more frequent updates
• Wider range of pre-built components and layouts

Cons of vue-admin-better

• Steeper learning curve due to more complex architecture
• Potentially heavier bundle size with additional features
• Less flexibility for customization compared to naive-ui-admin

Code Comparison

naive-ui-admin:

<template>
  <n-config-provider :theme="theme">
    <n-layout>
      <!-- Layout content -->
    </n-layout>
  </n-config-provider>
</template>

vue-admin-better:

<template>
  <el-config-provider :locale="locale">
    <el-container>
      <!-- Container content -->
    </el-container>
  </el-config-provider>
</template>

The code comparison shows that naive-ui-admin uses Naive UI components (n-config-provider, n-layout), while vue-admin-better utilizes Element Plus components (el-config-provider, el-container). This reflects the different UI libraries each project is built upon, influencing the overall structure and available components in each admin template.

Pros of vue-manage-system

• More established project with a larger community and longer history
• Comprehensive documentation and examples for easier adoption
• Supports both Vue 2 and Vue 3, offering flexibility for different project requirements

Cons of vue-manage-system

• Less frequent updates and potentially slower adoption of new features
• Heavier bundle size due to inclusion of multiple UI libraries and components
• May require more configuration and customization for specific use cases

Code Comparison

vue-manage-system:

<template>
    <div class="sidebar">
        <el-menu class="sidebar-el-menu" :default-active="onRoutes" :collapse="collapse" background-color="#324157"
            text-color="#bfcbd9" active-text-color="#20a0ff" unique-opened router>
            <template v-for="item in items">
                <template v-if="item.subs">
                    <el-submenu :index="item.index" :key="item.index">
                        <template #title>
                            <i :class="item.icon"></i>
                            <span>{{ item.title }}</span>
                        </template>
                        <template v-for="subItem in item.subs">
                            <el-submenu v-if="subItem.subs" :index="subItem.index" :key="subItem.index">
                                <template #title>{{ subItem.title }}</template>
                                <el-menu-item v-for="(threeItem, i) in subItem.subs" :key="i" :index="threeItem.index">
                                    {{ threeItem.title }}
                                </el-menu-item>
                            </el-submenu>
                            <el-menu-item v-else :index="subItem.index" :key="subItem.index">
                                {{ subItem.title }}
                            </el-menu-item>
                        </template>
                    </el-submenu>
                </template>
                <template v-else>
                    <el-menu-item :index="item.index" :key="item.index">
                        <i :class="item.icon"></i>
                        <template #title>{{ item.title }}</template>
                    </el-menu-item>
                </template>
            </template>
        </el-menu>
    </div>
</template>

naive-ui-admin:

<template>
  <n-layout-sider
    bordered
    collapse-mode="width"
    :collapsed-width="64"
    :width="220"
    :collapsed="collapsed"
    show-trigger
    @collapse="collapsed = true"
    @expand="collapsed = false"
  >
    <n-menu
      :collapsed="collapsed"
      :collapsed-width="64"
      :collapsed-icon-size="22"
      :options="menuOptions"
      :render-icon="renderIcon"
      :render-label="renderLabel"
      :expand-icon="expandIcon"
      key-field="name"
      :indent="18"
      @update:value="handleMenuClick"
    />
  </n-layout-sider>
</template>

Pros of vue2-manage

• Built with Vue 2, which has a larger ecosystem and more mature libraries
• Includes a wider range of pre-built components and features
• More comprehensive documentation and examples

Cons of vue2-manage

• Uses older technology stack (Vue 2) compared to naive-ui-admin's Vue 3
• Less modern UI design and styling
• May require more manual configuration for newer Vue features

Code Comparison

vue2-manage (Vue 2 component):

<template>
  <div>
    <el-table :data="tableData" style="width: 100%">
      <el-table-column prop="date" label="Date" width="180"></el-table-column>
      <el-table-column prop="name" label="Name" width="180"></el-table-column>
      <el-table-column prop="address" label="Address"></el-table-column>
    </el-table>
  </div>
</template>

naive-ui-admin (Vue 3 component with Composition API):

<template>
  <n-data-table :columns="columns" :data="data" :pagination="pagination" />
</template>

<script setup>
import { ref } from 'vue'
const columns = ref([/* column definitions */])
const data = ref([/* table data */])
const pagination = ref({ pageSize: 10 })
</script>

This comparison highlights the differences in syntax and structure between Vue 2 and Vue 3 components, as well as the use of different UI libraries (Element UI vs Naive UI).

Pros of iview-admin

• More mature and established project with a larger community
• Comprehensive documentation and examples
• Built-in support for internationalization (i18n)

Cons of iview-admin

• Based on older Vue 2 technology
• Less frequent updates and maintenance
• Heavier bundle size due to more built-in features

Code Comparison

iview-admin (Vue 2):

<template>
  <div>
    <Table :columns="columns" :data="data"></Table>
  </div>
</template>

<script>
export default {
  // Component logic
}
</script>

naive-ui-admin (Vue 3):

<template>
  <n-data-table :columns="columns" :data="data" />
</template>

<script setup>
import { NDataTable } from 'naive-ui'
// Component logic using Composition API
</script>

Key Differences

• naive-ui-admin uses Vue 3 and Composition API, offering better performance and more modern development practices
• iview-admin has a more extensive set of pre-built components and layouts
• naive-ui-admin has a cleaner, more minimalist design approach
• iview-admin offers more out-of-the-box features, while naive-ui-admin provides more flexibility for customization

Both projects serve as admin panel templates, but naive-ui-admin is more suited for developers looking for a modern, lightweight starting point, while iview-admin is better for those needing a comprehensive, feature-rich solution with extensive documentation.